Products
DEXTUPLOAD
Competitive Comparison
Functional Comparison
| Name of product |
DEXTUpload Professional |
SA-FileUp |
AspUpload 3.0 |
ABCUpload 4.6 |
| Manufacturer |
Devpia co. ltd. |
Softwares Artisans |
Persits Software |
WebSupergoo |
| Single License |
US $249 |
US $299 |
US $149 |
US $149 |
| Version |
3.0.5 |
5.0 |
3.0 |
4.6 |
| Functional |
| Auto creation of upload folder |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Support Unicode |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Support Blob data |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Modification for repletion error of IE 5.0 Form data |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Provide upload progress Information |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Support download |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Support image file Information (EXIF) |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
No |
| Watermark function |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Thumbnail function |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Relay download |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Forced Download |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Save file format Conversion |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| Download caching |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
| User's definition upload progress window |
Yes |
No |
No |
No |
Performance comparison
1) Capability Comparison (Test Environment)Windows 2000 Server
(CPU Pentium 4 2.8Ghz, RAM : 512MB, HDD : 80GB, LAN : 100Mbps)
2) Upload component for test
DEXTUpload Professional (DEVPIA Co., Ltd.)
SA-FileUp 5.0 (Software Artisans)
AspUpload 3.0 (Persits Software)
ABCUpload 4.6 (WebSupergoo)
3) Uploading one file
| Test condition : 20 MB (1 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
10% ~ 15% |
4 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
8 sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
4 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
20% ~ 30% |
7 sec |
| Test condition : 50 MB (1 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
15% ~ 20% |
12 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
30% ~ 40% |
22 sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
12 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
20% ~ 30% |
22 sec |
| Test condition : 130 MB (1 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
15% ~ 20% |
29 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
30% ~ 40% |
50sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
29 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
30% ~ 40% |
42 sec |
4) Uploading multi files
| Test condition : 20 MB (2 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
12% ~ 15% |
8 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
25 sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
9 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
20% ~ 20% |
14 sec |
| Test condition : 50 MB (2 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
15% ~ 20% |
22 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
30% ~ 40% |
49 sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
22 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
40% ~ 50% |
35 sec |
| Test condition : 130 MB (2 File) |
| Name of product |
CPU occupancy percentage |
UPLOAD TIME |
| DEXTUpload Professional |
15% ~ 20% |
57 sec |
| SA-FileUp 5.0 |
30% ~ 40% |
1min 52 sec |
| AspUpload 3.0 |
20% ~ 30% |
59 sec |
| ABCUpload 4.6 |
40% ~ 50% |
1min 24 sec |
5) Results
- Percentage of CPU
DEXTUpload Professional uses less than 20% of CPU resources compared to other
components. A low percentage of CPU use helps to guarantee the stability of the server
when multiple clients access at the same time.
- Percentage of MEMORY
As all upload components use ASP's Request.BinaryRead repetitively and additional use
of memory is not required, the amount of memory use is not significant.
- Update time (Speed)
In terms of upload speed, DEXTUpload Professional is the fastest, and ASPUpload has
the next best performance. However, SA-FileUp and ABCUpload are almost 2 times slower
than DEXTUpload Professional.
Login
